Skip to main content

OPINION: Plaigiarism claims surround Melania Trump's RNC speech, why the GOP blowing it off is not okay

buzzz worthy. . .
By Mona Austin




pla·gia·rismˈplājəˌrizəm/
nounthe practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.

Parts of Melania Trump's well rehearsed RNC speech sounded too familiar Monday  night. In fact, it sounded eerily similar to the woman whose shoes she would like to fill.  With a little research many viewers soon discovered why.  As journalist Jarrett Hill pointed out on Twitter, passages of the speech were lifted from First Lady Michelle Obama's 2008 DNC speech.

Like Hill, I noticed the copycatting right away.  In 2008 I stood on the DNC convention floor in Denver feet away from the then prospective first lady as she made a case for her husband to become the POTUS, albeit the first Black president in America.  Such a historic speech remained in my memory bank.  Realizing I had heard a few of the lines before, right after the delivery of the speech where over 30 million people tuned in I tweeted:


Indirectly, I was suggesting that Melania wanted to be like First Lady Michelle since she imitated portions of the speech.  Then, I fact checked the speech and confirmed my suspicion.  The verbiage, sentiment and tone in one paragraph--the paragraph that was the most inspiring in the speech-- were almost Mrs. Obama's words verbatim.  In fact, Mrs. Trump could have literally quoted the First Lady the words were so close.

At first Mrs. Trump was trending for all the right reasons. People were talking about how effective her keynote address was.  Many people commended her saying it was a good speech and she made a good impression.



Slovenia born, Mrs. Trump stood before America at the RNC last night to introduce  another side of herself and of her husband, GOP presidential hopeful Donald Trump.  Both of their images were stained from previous negative press. Formerly a model, Mrs. Trump was scrutinized for posing in sexy photos that resemble soft porn.  "The Donald" has been accused of being a shady businessman among other shortcomings.

Everything was going swell.  Mr. Trump briefly introduced his wife and quickly removed himself from the spotlight so that she could be the center of attention, showing a rare form of humility.  Wearing a white dress, she appeared confident and strong delivering the speech that had the potential to make or break her husband's candidacy.

What happened next was like the sinking of the Titanic.  The comments suddenly became highly critical when people saw video and printed proof that she lifted both words and ideas from First Lady Michelle Obama's 2008 Speech from various media outlets.  

Melania told Matt Lauer she wrote the speech herself with little help.  She sounded sincere, then today a statement was released in response to the controversy indicating she had the assistance of a team of speech writers, which would be the norm.  It would also be standard procedure that others reviewed the speech so she may not be the only person to blame.  Someone may be getting fired behind the scenes.

Trump's Director of Communication, Paul Manafort tried to shift the blame on Hillary Clinton saying on CNN this morning saying, "I mean, this is, once again, an example of when a woman threatens Hillary Clinton, how she seeks out to demean her and take her down. It's not going to work."  Chris Christie said in his legal opinion Mrs. Trump was using common words and the speech fiasco would soon blow over.   (Unbelievable.  Never mind the recycled words that actually flowed from  Melania's mouth.  Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama are somehow accountable for all the GOP's woes.)  

The RNC turning a deaf ear to plagiarism allegations is a damning reflection on the organization. The Trump's post-event silence on the matter is a reflection of their character. What dies this "do-what-I-wanna-do" attitude say about the type of leader Trump with be should he win? Plagiarism is a serious offense that is punishable by law. But the rule breakers don't seem to care. Owners of the song "We Are the Champions" (by Queen)stated via Twitter the campaign did not have their authorization to use the song at the event. In June a Queen group member said they did not want Trump using the same song. Trump's people claim they paid to use it.

From the statements the Trump camp issued today it is obvious that neither they, nor the RNC are going to insist that Mrs. Trump takes responsibility for mirroring words from First Lady Obama. The brand of the organization is already suffering from conflicting messages. The division that remains in the party is abundantly clear. Trump chose social conservative Mike Pence as a running mate to attract more mainline Republicans hoping to close that breach.  Lying about a speech that addressed family values could deter would be supporters. Admitting to making a mistake could lessen the perception the party is packed with hypocrites. The plagiarism allegations against Melania Trump can not be ignored.

Popular posts from this blog

Record-Breaking U.S.-Africa Business Summit Yields $2.5 Billion in Deals and Commitments

The U.S. Delegation, led by  Ambassador Troy Fitrell , Senior Bureau Official for African Affairs, included the senior-most officials advancing U.S. commercial engagement across Africa: Massad Boulos , Senior Advisor for Africa  Thomas Hardy , Acting Director, U.S. Trade and Development Agency Constance Hamilton , Assistant U.S. Trade Representative for Africa Connor Coleman , Head of Investments and Chief of Staff, U.S. International Development Finance Corporation Tamara Maxwell , Senior Vice President for Small Business, Export-Import Bank of the United States    The record turnout made clear that both U.S. and African leaders share a strong commitment to significantly expanding trade and investment.  The U.S. objective at the Summit was to secure key deals and commitments for U.S. companies and establish the conditions to boost U.S. exports and investment in Africa — advancing mutual prosperity in line with the Trump Administration’s  Commercial Diploma...

NEWLYWEDS: Bishop Marvin Winans weds after 30 years

  By Mona Austin One of the most eligible bacherlors in Christianity has tied the knot - Marvin Winans remarries After being single for almost 30 years, legendary gospel singer and Bishop Marvin L. Winans, Sr. has wed his long time girlfriend Deneen R. Carter. Carter is a 57-year-old physical therapist and minister at Perfecting Church in Detroit, founded by Winans. Little is known about the bride publicly. The gospel legend introduced the now Mrs. Winans as his fiance to the congregants of Perfecting in October of 2021. The couple had been in a relationship for 15 years. Pastor Winans was previously married to fellow gospel singer Vicki Winans (with whom he has two sons) for 16 years before they divorced in 1995. Held at the Colony Club in Detroit, MI, on April 22, the wedding was officiated by fellow COGIC Bishop Darrell Hines. "Let their lives be full of joy as they live according to your word," he prayed. If we are judging by floral count, this could be one of th...

Christian Rapper and Wife Reconcile, Renew Vows

Da' T.R.U.T.H. Celebrates Eighth Wedding Anniversary With Vow Renewal & Issues Public Statement Acclaimed Christian Hip Hop Artist Da’ T.R.U.T.H. renewed his wedding vows with beautiful wife Nicole Lambert earlier this week on Tuesday, June 15th—their eighth wedding anniversary. This special event punctuated the completion of their official restoration plan—marking the page of a new beginning and giving testimony to the redeeming power of reconciliation. Additionally, today, he has released a public letter to his family and supporters on his website www.datruth.net. The private ceremony, held in their backyard and attended by family and close friends, was officiated by Bishop Gilbert and Mrs. Debi Coleman—the marriage counseling team leading the Lambert’s restoration process. Also in attendance were Alvin Love & CeCe Winans (pictured in the insert), who have been walking intimately with the couple as supporting counselors and mentors. Da’ T.R.U.T.H.’s long-time frie...