Discipline Without Protection: Black Children and the Failure of School Anti-Bullying Policies
Learning in Fear: How Race Shapes Bullying and Accountability in My Child's Schools
By the end of the first Friday of the school year, my fourth-grade daughter came home in tears.
“Stand up for yourself,” I told her. “Use your words, and Mommy will handle the rest.”
Looking helpless, she replied, “But Mom, you don’t understand. I’ll get in trouble.”
For weeks, my child feared going to school—afraid not only of being bullied, but of defending herself. I had taught her to use her words and tell an adult if someone was taunting her. She believed she would be blamed if she spoke up. She had been instructed to only to physically fight ion self-defense as a last resort. Prince William County Public Schools, that fear is not unfounded. Under district policy, victims of physical altercations can be penalized and disciplined in the same manner as their aggressors. That reality terrified my daughter and left lasting emotional effects.
I soon realized she was not alone.
A viral video circulated online showing a Black father rapping to his daughter about her worth after she was bullied at school. The video resonated deeply with me—not because it was inspirational, but because it reflected a shared pain. My youngest daughter, then nine years old, was bullied for six consecutive weeks at a predominantly White school. Yet the school administration refused to label the behavior as bullying.
Both my daughters are African American.
Parents should not have to rely on hashtags, viral videos, or legal threats to protect their children from mistreatment at school. Schools should intervene swiftly, address harmful behavior honestly, and work to change school culture when bullying becomes normalized.
What Bullying Is—and What It Is Not
The National Education Association defines bullying as “systematically and chronically inflicting physical hurt and/or psychological distress on another.” Bullying can be physical, verbal, or social. It includes teasing, threats, destruction of property, exclusion, manipulation, and assault. Central to bullying is a real or perceived power imbalance. As the NEA notes, power is at the heart of a bully’s mindset.
There should be no effort—by teachers or administrators—to redefine or dilute this standard definition.
For African Americans, the right to an education free from fear carries historical weight. Black Americans were once legally denied education altogether, and that legacy informs why safety, dignity, and equal treatment in schools are non-negotiable today.
A Pattern of Abuse
In my daughter’s case, the bullying began verbally and escalated to physical aggression. While she was never severely beaten, the conduct she endured clearly met the definition of bullying.
Among the incidents:
-
A classmate told her she was “dirt,” threw dirt on her, and shoved her off a swing.
-
Another student wrote a story naming a witch after my daughter and mocked her during circle time.
-
That same student later stabbed my daughter with a pencil, allegedly because my child cut in line.
The pencil broke my daughter’s skin.
When we raised concerns, both the teacher and principal said, “We’re not saying she deserved it, but cutting in line may have triggered it.”
There is no justification for violence. While administrators said they agreed, their only response was to “investigate.”
When Accountability Is Avoided
I met repeatedly with the school counselor, teacher, vice principal, and principal. As a longtime school volunteer and a new member of the school advisory council, I expected collaboration. Instead, I encountered resistance.
After nearly 30 minutes of discussion, I said plainly, “I get the impression that none of you want to call this bullying.”
Silence.
Administrators explained that the other student had no prior history, that my daughter had responded verbally, and that the aggressor had social challenges. None of those explanations negate the definition of bullying. A victim’s attempt to defend herself does not absolve a perpetrator of responsibility.
My daughter’s experience went far beyond normal childhood conflict. Ignoring that reality compromised her safety and mental well-being.
I warned administrators that dismissing repeated degradation reinforces a broader societal message—one my child already hears too often—that her Black life does not matter.
Inclusion Without Accountability
The situation was further complicated by the school’s emphasis on inclusion. The aggressor reportedly struggled socially, and administrators appeared to extend heightened sensitivity toward her—at the expense of my child’s safety.
When I refused to endorse their interpretation of events, the principal told me, “This won’t work if we don’t have your support.”
I was unwilling to co-sign inadequate disciplinary measures that placed my daughter at risk. If the school’s interventions had been effective, we would not have reached that point.
No child should be placed in this position. No parent should be discouraged from advocating for justice.
Escalation—and Retaliation
The antagonizing behavior continued for months, affecting other students as well. By middle school, the bullying intensified—and I, too, became a target.
One administrator approached my car without greeting me, leaned inside the vehicle, and questioned why my daughter did not ride the bus. Another reprimanded me for picking my child up after school, stating staff were not “babysitters.”
My daughter was quiet, compliant, and completing her homework.
She did not ride the bus because she had been transferred to attend a specialty program. Ultimately, I brought the matter before the school board—where I saw immediate action for the first time.
A Broader Failure
This issue extends beyond my family. Black children should not have to “survive” a school day. Black families deserve educational environments free from discrimination and racialized bullying.
While I applaud parents who find creative ways to empower their children, individual coping strategies do not solve systemic failures. This is not a plea for sympathy or social media attention. It is a demand that schools enforce their own policies and ensure that classrooms are safe, nondiscriminatory spaces for learning.
Is that too much to ask?
A Call for Structural Change
A system that does not place the safetey and well beig of all on the same level needs to change. Mental or pshycological abuse that is often downplayed has long term affects and can not be ignored. Thee pereception or stereotype that Blacks or minorities are somehow inately stronger or more capable of tolerating stress and pain may feed in to how students in these groupsare treated by not only their peers but school staff and volunteers. Too address these
There is a clear need for programs that help minority children build confidence and navigate racially imbalanced school environments. A self-confidence and resilience camp focused on racism and classism would fill quickly in Prince William County. Equally necessary is mandatory, meaningful diversity training for educators.
My daughter’s experience exposed a truth too often ignored: when schools refuse to name bullying, they become complicit in it.
And that failure has consequences.
+++++++++
By the end of the first Friday of the first week of school, my fourth grader came home in tears. "Stand up for yourself," I demanded. "Use your words and mommy will handle the rest." Looking completely helpless she retorted, "But mom, you don't understand, I'll get in trouble." For weeks my daughter was fearful of attending school without being bullied and of defending herself. Why did she feel she would be blamed?
In Prince William County schools a victim of a physical attack will get penalized and may be subject to dismissal in the same way as the perpetuator. This reality has scared my child stiff and had residual mental affects.
I soon had proof that my daughter was not alone in her pain as a Black child attending a predominantly White school. A video combatting childhood bullying had gone viral wherein a Black father is rapping to his daughter about how special she is, after being fed up with her being bullied. Unfortunately, I can relate. My youngest daughter, 9 was bullied at school for six consecutive weeks, but equally as unfortunate, the school principal will not call the debasing treatment bullying. Both of our daughters are also African American. Parents with school aged children should not have to resort to hashtags and social media justice or accumulate legal expenses in defense of their children when they are mistreated or bullied at school. The school should intervene swiftly to prevent bullying and work to change the culture if it is a norm
The National Educators Association defines bullying as "systematically and chronically inflicting physical hurt and/or psychological distress on another. Bullying can be physical, verbal or social. Bullying is not just child’s play, but a frightening experience many students face every day. It can be as direct as teasing, hitting, threatening, destruction of property or forcing someone to do something against their will, or as indirect as in rumors, exclusion, or manipulation. Bullying involves a real or perceived power imbalance between the one who bullies and their target. The NEA Web site further states power is at the heart of a bully's mindset.
For African Americans, the right to an education without fear goes deeper based on the history in America that deprived Blacks of education. From slavery forward there In 1955? James was escorted
In my daughter's experience, it started with verbal abuse and eventually got physical. Fortunately she was never violently beaten. It goes without saying that my daughter has been bullied. Here is a brief summary of the intolerable deeds of her tiny tormentor:
She was told she was dirt, the other student threw dirt on her and shoved her on the swing.
One classmate wrote a story and named the witch in it after my daughter, made fun of her during circle time in front of their peers, and ultimately assaulted my daughter with a pencil because she allegedly cut in front of her in line, which is an infraction apparently equivalent to physical contact in the mind of her teacher and principal.
With regard to the pencil incident both the teacher and principal agreed, "I am not saying she deserved it, but her cutting could have triggered it." The pencil led broke my daughter's skin. There is no excuse for this violent behavior and they say they agree, yet their only solution is to "investigate."
I spoke to the counselor and principal initially and finally my husband and I met with the teacher, vice principal, principal and counselor to get a progress report on how the measures they took were taking effect. As a school volunteer for the last 5 years and new member of the school advisory council, I wanted to believe we met with mutual intent, but quickly realized our agenda was not exactly the same.
"I get the impression that none of you want to call this bullying," I noticed after talking for nearly half an hour. *blank stares* *complete silence* You could have heard a mosquito sneeze! They assured me they were working on the matter with the other student and her parents, but were reticent to call this string of recurring events what it is -- bullying.
Detecting a degree of feigning ignorance, I placed our discussion in a pertinent context,-- personal responsibility. I even went so far as to educate the group on the potential impact of persistent downgrading on our child's psyche, who is already constantly hearing in media that her Black life does not matter. Without clear resolution of this matter, I told them, they are reinforcing this sordid message.
There is one factor that complicates matters. In this case the school indicated the child struggles socially, We are in a school of inclusion wherein students with behavioral, mental or physical challenges are integrated into a regular classroom setting. The administration appears to be placating this child with a greater degree of sensitivity if not caution toward the other student. Educators so they could see how the reaches into greater society. Both principals assured me matters would not improve if I did not cooperate and trust them and their process. However, both my husband and I have engaged with the administration this entire time. The principal literally tried to turn the tables on me for refusing to co-sign their interpretation of events and accepting the mishandling of my child's abuse. ("Mrs. Austin this won't work if we on't have your support.") I am not willing to be silent and allow them to experiment with inadequate disciplinary interventions at the expense of my daughter's safety. I'm sharing this degree of detail simply to illustrate how much our family has already taken. If their methods were remotely effective we would not have arrived at this juncture. No child should placed in this position, nor should parents walk away from seeking justice for their children.
The school and parents are both at fault for not correcting teaching their children tolerance. Both parents and administrators should be somehow held accountable for ignoring the severity of bullying. By letting it slide they are putting the school at risk perpetuating dangerous behavior.
For the next several months I heard the same girl antagonize students in her class and others.
While I commend parents for finding creative ways to empower their children to rise above their obstacles such as the inspiring video to which I referred in the intro, this level of engagement only pacifies the problem. This is not a plea to recognize my daughter's value, beauty or worth. I don't want you to say her name, see her face or jump on the new social media bandwagon to push a cause. I want schools in Prince William County Virginia and throughout the nation to enforce the rules of the school board and governing educational agencies to ensure that my child safety and the environment in which she is receiving her education is not disruptive, discriminatory and most of all dangerous. I want the school to be an educational safe haven. Is that asking too much?
By middle school the bullying intensified and I was even targeted by certain administrators. One administrator walked up to my vehicle, did not greet me, stuck her head in th car and told me I could and questioned why I was not allowing my daughter r to ride the bus like everyone else. The school principal confronted me about picking my child up ate after school, no knowing if she had outside activities and stated she could not wait in the office because they staff members are not "baby sitter" My daughter only said quietly and completed her homework. She did not ride the bus because we were transferred to the school so she could participate in a specialty program and at the I'd had more than enough and took the issue to the school board where I noticed for the first time immediate action.
This matter is greater than our children. Black families deserve to live without discrimination and about children should not experience racially motivated bullying.
surviving a day at school.